Scottish Provident, Edinburgh, Building, Architect, Project, Images, Design, Info

Scottish Provident Edinburgh

Former HQ, St Andrews Square, New Town, Edinburgh, Scotland, UK

Scottish Provident

Scottish Provident Building Sale
Stockland Halladale buys 3-8 St Andrew Square, former Scottish Provident building, from ING Real estate. The competing Valad – EDI joint venture pulled out prior to the bid. 180108

News Update – Mar 2007
Scottish Provident site: full planning approval for £50m development by gareth hoskins architects for ING Real Estate 290307

Scottish Provident Building
Photo © Adrian Welch 2008

Scottish Provident – Redevelopment
Images not released to us but viewable on CEC Portal ref. 06/03441/FUL
Essentially St Andrew Square gets a massive injection of new architecture:
the principal Scottish Provident façade is retained but the traditional stone corner block and two narrow frontages to the east are to be demolished. The design is quite glassy with a vertical fin rhythm above street level. The proposals appear to be controversial to traditionalists – replacement of traditional decorative stone buildings that fit the patina of the area with a massive increase in glassy modern stuff – and many contemporary architects who favour an integral approach to this architectural classic. Façade retention is of course in itself a controversial concept with a similar relationship to ‘falseness’ as pastiche. The proposal has a clear relationship to the original Kininmonth concept in that it’s new facades slot between retained facades except there are two of the latter and one is Modern.

Scottish Provident Edinburgh
building: photo © adrian welch sep 2006

Scottish Provident – Submission Summary
3-8 St Andrew Square + 7-21 South St David Street, Edinburgh
Redevelopment of existing site (including the selective demolition of buildings) to form a mixed use development of office and retail uses and residential development
For ING Real Estate Investment Management
Application received 220806 validated 110906

The realities of the commercial marketplace more often than not control architecture: the ‘for let’ signs are still up at the Scottish Provident and the street level chipboard protection has been joined by growing green stains. Previously our former city leader controversially asked for this sixties building’s demolition to allow a modern building suited to current space and technical requirements. Just as with the former GPO building which slowly deteriorated over many years as it lay dormant (even sprouting small bushes on its neoclassical stone facade) there comes a point where the civic good surely overrides commercial determinants and the building is rescued. Witness Cardross.

[Adrian Welch 30 Oct 2006]

Scottish Provident restoration is part of a planning application by Gareth Hoskins Architects / CDA that was lodged with CEC Oct 2006: it involves demolition of the buildings around it, including the George Leslie wing on South St David Street: Application no. 06/03441/FUL

Jun 2005
Article re future of the Building by John Deffenbaugh + Letter from Frazer Hay

St Andrews Square
photo © Adrian Welch

Scottish Provident Building
Architect: William G Leslie of Rowand Anderson Kininmonth & Paul
Scottish Provident Building
photo © Adrian Welch 2008
Scottish Provident Building : article by John Deffenbaugh 2005

Also by Spence: John Lewis Edinburgh

Scottish Provident Building
photo © Adrian Welch

Comments / photos for the Scottish Provident page welcome

Scottish Provident Edinburgh – page