Architects: Edinburgh City Council
Date: 1970

Save Meadowbank : www.savemeadowbank.org

Building News 2008


image © Adrian Welch

Meadowbank Opposition
A repeat of the Caltongate controversy is muted by opponents to plans to build homes on the site of Meadowbank Stadium. Edinburgh Councillors opposed to the sale of land at Meadowbank say there will be thousands of public objections and calls for a public inquiry.

Commonwealth Games medallist Chris Black vowed to burn his Scotland team blazer in protest at the decision to demolish the existing stadium.

The value of the 8.5 acres of vacated land is put at £17m. The reduced facilities (relocated) at the east end of the site are costed at £25m. The new stadium capacity of 5,000 compares to the existing 16,500.

Meadowbank Stadium: View
Clearly the main issues are concerns about ‘selling off the silver’ ie reduction of public facilties, pressure on services such as roads and schools, and the usual ‘not in my backyard’ complaints. Architecture doesn’t appear to feature. The building is described as beyond saving, but if there is clear architectural / engineering evidence it appears to be hard to find (does anyone know?). The stadium is simple and strong, but not particularly elegant. It expresses structure in a way redolent of Pier Luigi Nervi’s stadiums in Rome. There are numerous architects in Scotland more than capable of replacing this Stadium with not only a better building but a more beautiful one. But there is a concern that a replacement might be worse, without an architect on board no-one can tell. It would be fair to say the City Council doesn’t have a particularly strong pedigree when it comes to civic buildings, landscape and artworks (just look at the pathetic sculpture outside the CEC HQ for proof).


Meadowbank Stadium, Edinburgh: photo © Adrian Welch

But on a personal note, as a youth I competed many times at the Stadium (I picked up various medals including a gold for Under 19 Scottish Triple Jump), and would be sad to see it go as a major Scottish sports arena. I've also started playing football here on the astroturf. We should be increasing our Sports venues rather than decreasing them, or letting them fall into disrepair. Meadowbank is not alone here, think for example of the now-closed Infirmary St Baths. Given Scotland’s issues with obesity and violence on the streets a vigorous augmentation of sports facilities seems overdue (thankfully the Commonwealth Games will help in Glasgow).

Like the fiery debate in London re saving Robin Hood Gardens (seventies concrete housing blocks) a key architectural issue is embodied energy – if there’s any way to save the structure by intelligent remodelling then the carbon saved is significant. The City of Edinburgh Council should have this issue at the forefront of their thinking regarding any developments.

Too many Scottish buildings are left to rot, with demolition then proposed as the ‘only option’, a fait accompli. Thankfully Edinburgh’s former GPO was saved, and the future of United Distillers and the former Infirmary St Baths look hopeful, but others such as the Gorgie Whisky Bond were less fortunate. In Dundee the surviving Linoleum factory becomes less saveable by the year, and in Glasgow the eco-towers proposal, aimed at halting demolition of tower blocks, is up against an imminent demolition timetable. And then there’s Cardross....

Views welcome: info@edinburgharchitecture.co.uk



Edinburgh sports facilities
Report out with recommendation to look at sale options of land at Meadowbank. Finance raised from a sale could fund an est.£10.5m shortfall in the Commonwealth Pool project plus a phased development of new facilities at Meadowbank. Detailed report to be presented to councillors in Spring. Dec 2007.

Reports in June 2007 suggest the Stadium will be reprieved but adjoining indoor & outdoor facilties look set to be sold off for development. Tied in with this is the strong suggestion that the Sighthill sports facility proposal is to be abandoned. Commonwealth Pool refurbishment & additional facilities however is full steam ahead.

Previous News Items:
Deadline passed end of May 2007 for comments on controversial plans to redevelop the Meadowbank Stadium site

Meadowbank Stadium - Future?
This expressive but rather leaden building's future looks bleak as Edinburgh Council look to a new £49m sports facility at Sighthill in the west of the city, part-funded by sportscotland, due to go on site in 2009. The Council aim to make Edinburgh the most physically active city in Europe by 2020, quite a target. Meanwhile the Royal Commonwealth Pool by Robert Matthew looks more likely to be saved, and the Ratho Adventure Centre similarly looks set to thrive within the total £100m investment for sports up to 2020.
270706

In Craigmillar plans are understood to include demolition of the ugly bulk of the Jack Kane Centre and replace it with a £28m sports facility including a velodrome, football barn and curling rink.

Built for the 1970 Commonwealth Games the Stadium is likely to be sold for residential land. There is a campaign group, Save Meadowbank, with a website at www.savemeadowbank.org

Background to Edinburgh's Sports Stadium

In a sea of mediocrity, the powerful forms of this stadium should be retained and upgraded. To the East we have the dull hulks of empty St Margaret’s House and Meadowbank House; across the road we have Macdonalds and six ugly ‘sheds’ that have absolutely no place so close to our great city centre and which should be replaced urgently. Such central land should have much higher density development, these sheds are indefensible at the Jewel, but beyond belief here. They should go, not the stadium.
10.05.03

Meadowbank Stadium: refurbish it
Meadowbank Stadium is the premier Athletics Venue in Scotland and Edinburgh's best Athletics Stadium & Sports Centre. Located off London Road in the east of the city, the stadium has a 16,000 capacity and was used twice for the Commonwealth Games.

Once the showcase venue for Scotland’s sporting hopes, Meadowbank today is little more than a national embarrassment. The City of Edinburgh Council is convinced it has a strong case for funding from the Scottish Executive. They believe that Meadowbank - and the Royal Commonwealth Pool - have contributed significantly to the nation’s sporting excellence as well as being assets for the local community.


Meadowbank Stadium, Edinburgh: image © Adrian Welch

There seems however to be no firm commitment to redevelop Meadowbank rather than build a new site.
10.05.03

Modern Architects

Scottish Architecture

Edinburgh : back to index

Another major Sports Venue in Edinburgh is Murrayfield Stadium

Meadowbank building

Manchester United Stadium + Brit Oval Stadium, both major projects in England but by Scottish-based architects

Nou Camp Stadium



Scottish National Sports Stadium

Edinburgh stadium : Hearts

Meadowbank Retail Park

Meadowbank Stadium was built for the 1970 Commonwealth Games. The Centre was also the main venue in 1986 when the Commonwealth Games returned to Edinburgh.

Buildings / photos for the Meadowbank Stadium Architecture pages welcome:
info@edinburgharchitecture.co.uk

Meadowbank Stadium - Building : page - adrian welch / isabelle lomholt